'Crescent Moon' Counts Down To Political Mayhem

Mar 24, 2015
Originally published on April 2, 2015 2:50 pm

The Shadow of the Crescent Moon is American-educated Pakistani writer Fatima Bhutto's first novel, but she already has three books to her credit: One volume of poetry, another a memoir (Songs of Blood and Sword, a title that seems apt, since she's the granddaughter of the executed Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, niece of the assassinated Benazir Bhutto and daughter of the murdered Murtaza Bhutto), and a compilation of survivors' accounts of the 2005 Pakistan earthquake. Which means she has been working for a while on a full head of steam — and now she has produced an intense and powerful work of fiction that takes us inside the lives of three Shia brothers from the town of Mir Ali in the tribal area of northwestern Pakistan — as Bhutto puts it, "a country within a country," on a day that may change their lives forever.

In this part of the world, tanks roll through the main streets, and soldiers — under the Pakistani flag of star and crescent moon — stand at just about every corner, except in those parts of town patrolled by Taliban irregulars armed with Kalashnikovs. The novel opens on a drizzly morning in Mir Ali; the three brothers are gathered around the breakfast table, speaking in subdued voices, their serious demeanor — particularly that of the youngest brother — hinting at a dangerous political plot in the works.

We're alerted to this as well by a countdown: 9:00 AM, Bhutto cues us, 9:25, and so forth. By focusing on portions of each of the next three hours, she moves us, in Day of the Jackal-style, closer and closer to an afternoon that promises violence and political mayhem involving a visiting political dignitary.

But Bhutto's as interested in the psychology of the brothers as she is in building suspense. The eldest, Aman Erum, has recently returned from college in the United States, where he studied business and marketing. In order to start a business in his hometown, free from the constrictions of life under military rule and terrorist threat, he has made a dangerous bargain with an officer from the occupying national army.

Hayat, the youngest brother, is currently enrolled at the local college, which since the arrival of the army in Mir Ali has become a haven for political resistance. His life as a radical has become intertwined with that of Samarra, a bright, beautiful and rebellious young woman, once the childhood friend of Aman Erum, now estranged.

The middle brother, Sikander, is an overworked physician on the staff of the local hospital with, as it happens, problems more personal than political on his mind. His wife, Mina, unhinged by the death of their 6-year-old son in a Taliban attack on a local hospital, has made it her duty to attend as many funerals around town as will allow her entrance.

With the clock ticking, Aman Erum takes a rattle-trip taxi on a trip to pray — safely, he hopes — at a mosque some distance across town. Hayat, with Samarra perched behind him, hops on his motorbike and heads out for a fateful rendezvous with other members of a conspiratorial group of students. Sikander, after retrieving his wife from yet another funeral where she has created an unwanted stir, puts her in the passenger seat of a hospital van and sets off on a mission of mercy to deliver a child in difficult labor, a mission that takes him directly into a melodramatic encounter at a Taliban checkpoint.

Even as these distinct but intertwined motives build in the actions of the main characters, Crescent Moon rises above melodrama, tying us to the page at the same time it presents us with larger questions about the troubled people of this troubled region. Bhutto works with the delicacy of a poet and the prime-time urgency of a front-line correspondent in order to capture these tortured cries of her beloved country.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.


Our reviewer Alan Cheuse is recommending a book that's a journey deep into Pakistan. He just picked up the first novel from Fatima Bhutto. She's related to the Bhuttos of the political dynasty. Her book is "The Shadow Of The Crescent Moon."

ALAN CHEUSE, BYLINE: The story opens rather quietly in the tribal territories of northwest Pakistan. Three adult brothers gather around the breakfast table in a Shia household early on a drizzly morning on the first day of the Muslim holiday Eid. Violence feels imminent, so the first order of business is to make sure they don't all pray together at the same mosque. As Bhutto writes, it's too dangerous - too risky to place all the family together in one mosque that could easily be hit. They no longer know by whom.

The book counts down toward an explosive afternoon. The eldest brother, Aman Erum, and erstwhile businessman with secret ties to the ruling military takes a rattletrap taxi on a trip to pray at a mosque some distance from the house. Hayat hops on his motorbike and heads out for a fateful rendezvous with other members of a conspiratorial group of university students.

Sikander, the middle brother and a physician at the local hospital, sets out on a mission of mercy to deliver a baby in difficult labor and runs into a Taliban checkpoint. Ordered to identify himself, Sikander cannot bear to say the truth, that he's Shia.

Bhutto herself goes all out to set the truth before the reader -the difficult and sometimes confusing and disturbing truth of life in this part of the world. She works with the delicacy of a poet and the primetime urgency of a frontline correspondent in order to capture the torturous outcries of her beloved country.

SIEGEL: The author is Fatima Bhutto, and her new novel is "The Shadow Of The Crescent Moon." Alan Cheuse had our review. His latest book is "Prayers For The Living." Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.