Immigrant Communities Were The 'Geographic Solution' To Predator Priests

18 hours ago
Originally published on November 8, 2018 7:41 pm

Catholic Church leaders in Los Angeles for years shuffled predator priests into non-English-speaking immigrant communities. That pattern was revealed in personnel documents released in a decades-old legal settlement between victims of child sex abuse by Catholic priests and the Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles.

Now clergy sex abuse victims throughout California are calling on the state's attorney general to investigate clergy abuse and force church officials to release more information about their role covering it up. The goal is to discover how wide-spread the practice of hiding abusers in immigrant communities really was.

Manuel Barragan was one of those victims.

After Father Carlos Rodriguez abused a child in south Los Angeles, the Catholic Archdiocese of Los Angeles sent him into an out-of-state treatment program for pedophile priests. Then, local officials brought him back to minister to Spanish speakers in the Office of Family Life.

Barragan first met Rodriguez three decades ago.

"He put on that suit to portray himself as a man of God, and he was an imposter," says Barragan. "He was a fake dude trying to get into little boys and little girls pants, and that's what he did.

Barragan grew up in the farmworker community of Santa Paula, north of Los Angeles. His devout Catholic, Mexican immigrant parents met Rodriguez through a marriage retreat program.

"I'm 42 years old now, but let's rewind the tape," says Barragan. "Let me be 11 years old really quick. There's trust here."

The priest sexually molested Barragan for years, inside the family's home and on campouts. Barragan self-medicated with drugs and alcohol for a decade before he could tell his family about the abusive priest.

"I would come into my parents house and I would see pictures of this guy on the wall," says Barragan. "They're put on the high pedestal, like 'This is a man of God who has blessed our family.' I'm devastated. Don't you see what he did to us?"

When he did tell them, Barragan's parents reported the priest. Three years later, representatives from the L.A. Archdiocese knocked on Barragan's door and checked him into substance abuse counseling where he started therapy.

Records opened, patterns found

This was 2002, and California had just removed the statute of limitations for child abuse victims. Barragan joined a lawsuit against the L.A. Archdiocese that eventually resulted in a $660 million settlement involving more than 500 abuse cases.

"Not many regions around the country have had that," says attorney Tony DeMarco, who represented Barragan and has been representing clergy sex abuse survivors since.

DeMarco says that settlement forced local Catholic officials to turn over thousands of pages of personnel files on accused priests. Those files showed how higher-ups repeatedly sent predators into communities where they knew people were less likely to speak up.

"Blatant statements as to 'there is no need to take corrective action, because folks who were undocumented won't report,'" DeMarco says. "That's in some of these files."

There are dozens of examples of immigrant communities thrown under the bus.

"This is complete pattern," says Patrick Wall, a legal advocate who coined the term 'the geographic solution' to describe the church's actions.

Before advocating for child abuse victims with Jeff Anderson & Associates, Wall was a young 'fixer' priest for the Catholic Church in Minnesota, hired to take over parishes from 6 different accused pedophiles who'd been moved away.

Church dependence

The country's largest Catholic Archdiocese in Los Angeles is more than three-quarters Hispanic and largely immigrant.

"The Latino community has never really been able to come with grips with this," says Wall. "They were never informed of this."

There's a good reason Latino Catholics view this issue differently than the rest of the Church, says Cecilia González-Andrieu, who teaches theology at Loyola Marymount University.

"The Latino Church was already in a really painful spot and needed the Catholic Church with moral authority to continue to fight for our human rights," she says.

Immigrant Catholics depend on the Church to speak out on issues related to legal status, poverty and healthcare.

"With this scandal cropping up, that voice is now completely gone from the conversation," González-Andrieu says.

The turmoil continues, she says, because Catholic leaders have been managing the problem, instead of addressing it head-on.

"We need to deal with that proactively," González-Andrieu says.

The Archdiocese of Los Angeles says it changed its ways 15 years ago, adding zero tolerance abuse policies, employee trainings and victims' assistance programs.

But it was only through legal action that Manuel Barragan learned how Church leaders facilitated his abuse. He says it'll take a statewide investigation by prosecutors to deliver justice to thousands more like him.

"Part of that process is accountability," says Barragan. "How do you move on from this if nobody's taking responsibility?"

With 10 million Catholics in the state, victims' advocates say there's much more to uncover.

Copyright 2018 KPCC. To see more, visit KPCC.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

Now to California where survivors of clergy child sex abuse are calling on the state attorney general to investigate abuse by Catholic priests and cover-ups by church officials. Survivors also want information about the church moving abusive priests into immigrant communities where victims were less likely to speak up. From member station KPCC, Aaron Schrank reports. And a warning to our listeners - there are some graphic details of abuse.

AARON SCHRANK, BYLINE: The Archdiocese of Los Angeles sent Carlos Rodriguez into a treatment program for pedophile priests after he abused a child in South LA. Then they brought him back to minister to Spanish speakers in the Office of Family Life.

MANUEL BARRAGAN: He put on that suit to portray himself as a man of God, and he was an impostor.

SCHRANK: Manuel Barragan first met Rodriguez three decades ago.

BARRAGAN: He was a fake dude trying to get into little boys' and little girls' pants, and that's what he did.

SCHRANK: Barragan, who's now 42, grew up in the farm worker community of Santa Paula north of Los Angeles. He's devout Catholic Mexican immigrant parents met Rodriguez through a marriage retreat program.

BARRAGAN: Let me be 11 years old really quick. You know, there's trust here.

SCHRANK: The priest sexually molested Barragan for years. He self-medicated with drugs and alcohol for a decade.

BARRAGAN: I would come into my parents' house, and I would see pictures of this guy on the wall.

SCHRANK: He eventually did tell his parents about the abusive priest.

BARRAGAN: They're put on a high pedestal. Like, this is a man of God who has blessed our family. I'm devastated. I'm like, don't you see what he did to us?

SCHRANK: The family reported the priest. Three years later, representatives from the LA Archdiocese knocked on Barragan's door. They checked him into substance abuse counseling, and he started therapy. This was 2002, and California had just removed the statute of limitations for child abuse victims. Barragan joined a lawsuit against the LA Archdiocese that eventually resulted in a $660 million settlement involving more than 500 abuse cases.

TONY DEMARCO: Not many regions around the country have had that.

SCHRANK: Attorney Tony DeMarco says that settlement forced local Catholic officials to turn over thousands of pages of personnel files. They showed how higher-ups repeatedly sent predators into communities where they knew people were less likely to speak up.

DEMARCO: Blatant statements as to there is no need to take corrective action because folks who are undocumented won't report. That's in some of these files.

SCHRANK: There are dozens of examples of immigrant communities thrown under the bus, says Patrick Wall, a legal advocate who coined the term the geographic solution to describe the church's actions.

PATRICK WALL: This is a complete pattern.

SCHRANK: The country's largest Catholic archdiocese is more than three quarters Hispanic and largely immigrant.

WALL: The Latino community has never really been able to come to grips with this.

CECILIA GONZALEZ-ANDRIEU: The Latino church was already in a really painful spot and needed the Catholic Church with moral authority to continue to fight for our rights.

SCHRANK: Loyola Marymount University theologian Cecilia Gonzalez-Andrieu says immigrant Catholics need the church to speak out on issues related to legal status, poverty and health care.

GONZALEZ-ANDRIEU: With this scandal, that voice now is completely gone.

SCHRANK: She says the turmoil continues because Catholic leaders have been managing the problem instead of addressing it head-on.

GONZALEZ-ANDRIEU: We need to deal with that proactively.

SCHRANK: The LA Archdiocese says it's changed its ways with zero tolerance abuse policies, employee training and victims assistance programs. But it was only through legal action that Manuel Barragan learned how church leaders facilitated his abuse. He says it'll take a statewide investigation by prosecutors to deliver justice to thousands more like him.

BARRAGAN: Part of that process is accountability. How do you move on from this if nobody's taking responsibility?

SCHRANK: With 10 million Catholics in the state, victims advocates say there's much more to uncover. For NPR News, I'm Aaron Schrank in Los Angeles. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.